Bobbi Brown Extra Tinted Moisturizing Balm

Makeup in glass jars is hard to resist. What is it about a glass pot of lotion or potion that just beckons us in?

Foundation - Makeup - Tinted Moisturiser

I want to like this so badly that I keep trying it, which never ends well.  I love the idea of it.  I love the look of it.  I don’t love the smell of it, but hey, that’s personal preference and there are thousands of people who love the cucumber-meets-botanical scent of Bobbi Brown skin care.  But here’s the real deal with this product; it made my skin break out. 

The first time this was applied on my skin it was by a lovely lady at Liberty in London, and it felt cooling and plumping and everything like the tinted moisturiser I’d been searching for. Back before they went all BB and CC when they actually felt like a moisturiser, with tint in it. It didn’t pack a lot of coverage but it was enough to tone down the redness and warm things up from deathly-pale to ‘healthy’.  I left looking ‘fresh’ and dewy like someone who has juicy, hydrated skin. Mission. Accomplished.

Unfortunately, when I used it myself the next day, I noticed that irritating ‘pilling’ effect as I rubbed the product in with my hands.  What was I doing wrong? I gave it the benefit of the doubt, maybe it just didn’t work with my moisturiser, maybe I needed an exfoliation. 

Next attempt, same thing. On top of that, it quickly became clear this little tub was breaking my (usually clear) skin out.  I would stop using it, the skin would clear, start it again – bam – spots. 

Full disclosure; I decided to test out the standard Bobbi Brown moisturiser, the Vitamin Enriched Face Base which is loved by many and touted as a great primer for makeup.  It has that same scent, love it or hate it, and what do you know, my skin hates it.  Cue the tears of a Bobbi Brown loyalist. Clearly, there is an ingredient here that just doesn’t sit well on my skin, which was truly disappointing for a Bobbi Brown devotee like me.

For many of you this face tint may be a wondrous product.  It’s the perfect sort of no makeup makeup that enhances your face and makes everything look even toned and youthful. Sadly, it’s just not for me, and reinforces the sensible advise of asking for a sample before committing to a face product.  It’s just not worth the irritation – literally.